OurHeroesTravel LogoOurHeroesTravel LogoOurHeroesTravel Logo
  • My Bookings
Destination
Check in / Check out
Rooms & Guests

Free Membership

Becoming a member gives you instant access to amazing deals with no hidden fees. Seriously.

Exclusive Savings

Travel in style or on a budget. Get access to up to 50% off hotels, with our exclusive unpublished rates.

Travel Your Way

Book at over one million hotels in 155,000 cities in 220 countries. The world is your oyster.

OurHeroesTravel LogoOurHeroesTravel LogoOurHeroesTravel Logo

Quick Links

  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy

Connect with OurHeroesTravel

FacebookInstagram
© 2025 OurHeroesTravel. All rights reserved.
Save more on this travel experience by joining the club
1 / 50
Close to Everything
Location
9
50 photos
Overview & Photos
Rooms
Amenities
About
Reviews
Map

Amara Cay Resort

Islamorada
4-Star Hotel
8.2
Excellent
254 Reviews
Top Reasons to Book
  • Guests Love It
    Guests give this property a very good rating of 8.2/10
  • Top Rated Location
    Guests rate the location 9/10
  • Very Clean
    Guests rate the cleanliness 8.5/10
8.2
Guest Rating
Cleanliness
8.5
Staff
9.3
Location
9.0
Top Amenities
  • Swimming Pool
  • Wheelchair accessible
  • Restaurant(s)
  • Non-Smoking Rooms Available
  • Fitness center
Rooms

Amenities

  • Swimming Pool
  • Garden
  • Golf Course
  • Meeting/Banquet Facilities
  • Room Service
  • Air Conditioning
  • Bar
  • 24-Hour Front Desk
  • Express Check-In/Check-Out
  • Elevator
  • Water sports
  • Fishing
  • Cycling
  • Fax/photocopying
  • Diving
  • Snack bar
  • Shared lounge/TV area
  • Beachfront
  • Wheelchair accessible
  • On-site parking
  • outdoor pool
  • Poolside bar
  • Accessible parking
  • Designated Smoking Area
  • Family Rooms
  • Heated pool
  • Private Beach
  • Restaurant(s)
  • Snorkeling
  • Sun Deck
  • Convenience Store
  • Non-Smoking Rooms Available
  • Electric vehicle charging station
  • Pool with view
  • Wine/champagne
  • Fruits
  • Pet bowls
  • Outdoor furniture
  • Fence around pool
  • Kids' pool

About

Hotel Features

This beachfront hotel is located in Islamorada, Florida and features transfer services within 3.7 mi from the property. WiFi is included in the resort fee. Guests can relax on beachside hammocks or enjoy the outdoor pool at Amara Cay Resort. An on-site fitness center is available, as well as a meeting space. A flat-screen TV, work desk, and safety deposit box comes standard in every guestroom. Bicycle rentals and luggage storage are offered on site. Sample a custom cocktail at the Tiki Bar or experience Amara Cay Resort’s restaurant, ReelCatch. The History of Diving Museum is 3 mi away. Guests will be 8 minutes’ drive from Anne’s beach. Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State park is 8 minutes’ drive.

Guest Policies

Check-in
After 16:00
Check-out
Before 11:00
Room Rates
All rates displayed are for double occupancy unless otherwise noted.

Important Information

Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply. Please inform Amara Cay Resort of your expected arrival time in advance. You can use the Special Requests box when booking, or contact the property directly using the contact details in your confirmation. A damage deposit of USD 200 is required on arrival. This will be collected by credit card. You should be reimbursed within 7 days of check-out. Your deposit will be refunded in full via credit card, subject to an inspection of the property. The shuttle service available from 7:00 a.m. – 11:00 p.m. Tuesday – Saturday. Sunday & Monday will remain 3:00 p.m. – 11:00 p.m Please note information about in-room dining: In-room dining working hours: Breakfast 7:00 - 11:00 Daily Lunch and Dinner 11:30 - 23:00 Daily The guest laundry at Amara Cay is complimentary and soaps are available for purchase. Hotel resort fee includes the following: Access to three resorts in the Islamorada Resort Collection including amenities, activities, multiple beaches, four pools, a fitness center, and culinary destinations, Rum Runner water taxi, local shuttle service between MM77-MM85, daily bicycle rental, daily paddleboard and kayak rentals, one welcome drink per guest, complimentary coffee service in the lobby 7 am – 10 am, one reusable water bottle (per guest per stay), enhanced Wi-Fi, self-parking, and beach and pool chaise lounges and umbrellas. A damage deposit of USD 200.0 is required at checkin. This will be collected by credit card. You should be reimbursed within 7 days of checkout via credit card, subject to an inspection of the property.

Reviews

8.2
  • Staff
    9.3
  • Cleanliness
    8.5
  • Location
    9.0
  • 10
    Exceptional
    Aug 04, 2025
    Chris
    Family with Teens
    • What did you like most?
      The care they put into everything.
  • 10
    Exceptional
    Aug 04, 2025
    Deigo
    Family with Young Children
    Exceptional
    • What did you like most?
      Staff!

Location

Amara Cay Resort
80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL
9
Exceptional
Location Score
  • Standard Room King ROOM ONLY

      • 1 King
    Sleeps up to 2 Guest
    Non-Refundable
    Book now, pay now
      $274
      Per Night
      $364.31
      Total Including Taxes & Fees
      Book Now

      Only 1 room left at this price!

    • Standard View Studio Suite King Bed ROOM ONLY

        • 1 King
      Sleeps up to 2 Guest
      Non-Refundable
      Book now, pay now
        $274
        Per Night
        $364.31
        Total Including Taxes & Fees
        Book Now

        Only 1 room left at this price!

      • Matacumbe Courtyard View King Bed ROOM ONLY

          • 1 King
        Sleeps up to 2 Guest
        Non-Refundable
        Book now, pay now
          $293
          Per Night
          $385.70
          Total Including Taxes & Fees
          Book Now

          Only 1 room left at this price!

        • Matacumbe Courtyard View King Lanai ROOM ONLY

            • 1 King
          Sleeps up to 2 Guest
          Non-Refundable
          Book now, pay now
            $312
            Per Night
            $407.09
            Total Including Taxes & Fees
            Book Now

            Only 1 room left at this price!

          • Alligator Reef Partial Ocean View Room King Bed ROOM ONLY

              • 1 King
            Sleeps up to 2 Guest
            Non-Refundable
            Book now, pay now
              $369
              Per Night
              $471.27
              Total Including Taxes & Fees
              Book Now

              Only 1 room left at this price!

            • Alligator Reef Partial Ocean View Room Two Queens ROOM ONLY

                • 2 Queen
              Sleeps up to 2 Guest
              Non-Refundable
              Book now, pay now
                $388
                Per Night
                $492.67
                Total Including Taxes & Fees
                Book Now

                Only 1 room left at this price!

              • Oceanfront Room King Bed ROOM ONLY

                  • 1 King
                Sleeps up to 2 Guest
                Non-Refundable
                Book now, pay now
                  $426
                  Per Night
                  $535.47
                  Total Including Taxes & Fees
                  Book Now

                  Only 1 room left at this price!

                • Oceanfront Room Two Queen Beds ROOM ONLY

                    • 2 Queen
                  Sleeps up to 2 Guest
                  Non-Refundable
                  Book now, pay now
                    $445
                    Per Night
                    $556.86
                    Total Including Taxes & Fees
                    Book Now

                    Only 1 room left at this price!

                  • Alligator Reef Oceanfront Room King Lanai ROOM ONLY

                      • 1 King
                    Sleeps up to 2 Guest
                    Non-Refundable
                    Book now, pay now
                      $511
                      Per Night
                      $631.74
                      Total Including Taxes & Fees
                      Book Now

                      Only 1 room left at this price!

                    • Oceanfront Room Two Queen Beds with Lanai ROOM ONLY

                        • 2 Queen
                      Sleeps up to 2 Guest
                      Non-Refundable
                      Book now, pay now
                        $530
                        Per Night
                        $653.14
                        Total Including Taxes & Fees
                        Book Now

                        Only 1 room left at this price!

                      • Standard Oceanfront One Bedroom Suite Two Queen Beds ROOM ONLY

                          • 2 Queen
                        Sleeps up to 2 Guest
                        Non-Refundable
                        Book now, pay now
                          $653
                          Per Night
                          $792.22
                          Total Including Taxes & Fees
                          Book Now

                          Only 1 room left at this price!

                        • Premium Oceanfront One Bedroom Suite Two Queen Beds ROOM ONLY

                            • 2 Queen
                          Sleeps up to 2 Guest
                          Non-Refundable
                          Book now, pay now
                            $748
                            Per Night
                            $899.19
                            Total Including Taxes & Fees
                            Book Now

                            Only 1 room left at this price!

                          $274
                          per night
                          $309.18
                          including taxes & fees
                          $274
                          per night
                          including taxes & fees
                          $274
                          per night
                          $309.18
                          including taxes & fees
                          $274
                          per night
                          including taxes & fees